Comparing Popup Builder Tools in 2025 — Which One Actually Delivers?

Hey all!

I’m comparing popup tools for 2025 and I’m stuck between a dozen options. There’s Sleeknote, OptiMonk, OptinMonster, Ninja Popup, Adoric, Mailmunch, Poptin, Hello Bar, Privy, Sumo, and WisePops.

I run a Shopify store and we’re growing fast, but I need something that’s:

  • Easy to use, mobile-friendly

  • Strong with targeting rules (exit, cart, scroll, device)

  • Integrates with Mailchimp/Klaviyo

  • Affordable and scalable

  • Bonus for gamification!

What’s working for everyone in 2025?